Hmm... Well, considering the state of the other two threads, I don't see why you couldn't make it. It may kind of feel like beating a dead horse, but who knows, maybe you'll have more success (I guess Shinryuu's was a success, but who knows where that guy is xD)
So if I made an Anime Recommendation thread where instead of having long, detailed reviews for each of the recommended animes, I just have a short 2-3 sentences for each recommended anime that speaks briefly on it and is updated maybe seasonly and other people can suggest animes to me to put into the recommendation list.. will it get deleted? I mean, there are 2 pretty inactive threads right now. It can be a thread maintained by a few people, too.