SotW #33 Poll

[Aevitas]

Here are our signatures to vote on for this week!

Galadin:
[1]



[2]




Sean1616:




NekoMizu:

I encourage everyone to give feedback on the entry they voted for, both to encourage the graphicker who made it and help them grow as an artist. Not to mention it'll give members a better chance to see the poll. Let me know if I missed anyone. Also just a note guys, please try to vote on the aesthetics of the entry, not for your favorite character, etc. First and foremost, this is meant to be a graphics contest to help graphic artists improve their skills.

The poll will close in one week. Encourage other forum members to vote on the polls too if you can, even if they didn't participate. Good luck everyone!

[Cookies]

Gotta go with Waffle's one here, it's just so damn smexy.

[BRKNglassIncarnate]

Can't decide between Galadin #1, Waffle's, and Mizu's

[Sean1616]

Voted for Mizu's :>

[Dúrthalion]

Well... what can I say? I don't feel that the signatures are their usual standard this week. Galadín (1) doesn't really inspire me too much but it is a good job all the same. Galadín (2) is much better but still not the usual. Sean1616 is good to...up to a point.I don't think the text adds to the signature, and I always believe that if it is not an addition, it's a subtraction. NekoMizu...sorry, it just hurts my eyes to look at it.

My vote goes to Galadín (2)

[Galadín]

Well... what can I say? I don't feel that the signatures are their usual standard this week. Galadín (1) doesn't really inspire me too much but it is a good job all the same. Galadín (2) is much better but still not the usual. Sean1616 is good to...up to a point.I don't think the text adds to the signature, and I always believe that if it is not an addition, it's a subtraction. NekoMizu...sorry, it just hurts my eyes to look at it.

My vote goes to Galadín (2)

Honesty at its finest ^^! Still, I can't object too much.

[Kayarine]

I voted before but I didn't have time to write down my reasons... :x

I voted for Galadín's first because I like the idea/concept of the signature. I think some color tweaking would do wonders to make it blend better, however.

I don't like the second one much because the main renders are far apart, which doesn't give it much of a focal point. And the sparkle right on top of Lightning's and Serah's faces on the background looks kind of silly. It'd look better if it was just a regular faded spot rather than sparkle-shaped.

The color of Sean's signatures are nice, but I think the lighting/shading is a little weird. The shadows at the top end too abruptly, making it look like the image has a slight fold mark there. Serah doesn't blend very well with the right side of the signature also, the background ends too abruptly.

I like how the render is vibrant yet soft in Mizu's signature. But I think it's a little messy. I also think the style (more paper-ish) doesn't suit the render (which is a CG.)

[Sean1616]

Knock knock, bumpity bump. :3