SotW #36 Poll

**Kayarine** · 04-10-2012 05:33 AM

Here are our signatures to vote on for this week!

Signature #1 (Sean1616)

Signature #2: (Galadín)

I encourage everyone to give feedback on the entry they voted for, both to encourage the graphicker who made it and help them grow as an artist.

Not to mention it'll give members a better chance to see the poll. Also just a note guys, please try to vote on the aesthetics of the entry, not for your favorite character, etc. First and foremost, this is meant to be a graphics contest to help graphic artists improve their skills.

The poll will close in one week. Encourage other forum members to vote on the polls too if you can, even if they didn't participate.

Good luck everyone!

**LightningxFATE** · 04-10-2012 05:42 AM

(Sean1616)
The colors and the text looks amazing , I really like this signature because the color scheme really brings out the sig. Especially all the other characteristics of the sig look amazing

(Galadin)
I like this signature , Its really soft and simple which I like about it. The colors and the flowering around the picture really bring out Serah's eyes. But there is more potential to make this sig a little bit better.

**BRKNglassIncarnate** · 04-10-2012 06:15 AM

mmwaffle's sig is so coooorruu

**Saiyokuro** · 04-10-2012 07:25 AM

I voted for sig 1.
I want to say this now. I am not an experienced sig maker (as the really poorly made sig in my sig will show you) so please if i am explaining any of this wrong then please let me know or just ignore it.
my reason: I like how everything works together in it. although i think the butterfly could be moved to a different spot in the sig other than that and the mini text in it I have no complaints on it.
Why i didn't pick sig 2: It's not that its bad or anything but i think that more than just the small section of the characters face coiuld be used in the sig and maybe it could be moved more to a side so it isn't in the base center of the sig to kind of draw some more attention to it and the rest of the sig itself. and also on that note a little more could be added to the outer reaches of the sig to give it even more of a draw focus.
again if i'm wrong on any of this please correct me as i am not an experienced sig maker.

**Cookies** · 04-10-2012 10:21 AM

To be honest, I don't think either of them are overly "springy" (where's all the green?) but I do slightly prefer Ian's.

**Aevitas** · 04-10-2012 10:24 AM

I also voted for sig #1. The colors work really well with each other, and gave me a feeling of "spring." The only suggestion I would make is to move the girl over a little bit more to the left, because my brain wants to work her into a "rule of thirds."